专题:城市交通公平与出行效率

“人本转向”下的城市步行环境测度与评价方法研究进展

  • 杨文越 ,
  • 朱钰娴
展开
  • 华南农业大学林学与风景园林学院, 广州 510642
杨文越,副教授,研究方向为建成环境与出行行为、公众健康,电子信箱:yangwenyue900780@163.com

收稿日期: 2023-07-17

  修回日期: 2023-10-20

  网络出版日期: 2024-04-15

基金资助

教育部人文社会科学研究项目(21YJC840032);广东省普通高校特色创新类项目(2021WTSCX013);广东省自然科学基金面上项目(2022A1515011259)

Review on measurement and assessment methods for urban walking environment in the context of “human-oriented turn”

  • YANG Wenyue ,
  • ZHU Yuxian
Expand
  • College of Forestry and Landscape Architecture, South China Agricultural University, Guangzhou 510642, China

Received date: 2023-07-17

  Revised date: 2023-10-20

  Online published: 2024-04-15

摘要

对城市步行环境已有研究进行梳理,将其测度和评价方法归纳为客观和主观2大类。客观方法主要从中宏观尺度对城市步行适宜性进行测度,对微观步行环境的测度相对较薄弱;主观方法则主要应用于中微观尺度步行环境评价,不仅关注行人对客观建成环境的主观感知,同时还考虑了个人的步行能力、步行偏好以及社会经济属性的影响。在具体方法和数据方面,客观测度方法主要基于GIS技术和数据,主观评价方法主要基于问卷量表和实地参与式手段。研究方法的发展趋势方面,随着3D GIS模型、街景图像数据和机器学习方法的应用,客观方法开始从二维平面的步行适宜性测度转向三维立体测度,研究尺度亦从中宏观转向微观的人本尺度,从人本视角考虑更多精细化、满足视觉审美需求的步行环境要素;主观方法则转向结合机器学习、大数据算法、虚拟现实技术和可穿戴式生理传感器等新的技术与方法获取行人对步行环境的主观感知。提出了人本转向下未来中国城市步行环境测度与评价的研究趋势。

本文引用格式

杨文越 , 朱钰娴 . “人本转向”下的城市步行环境测度与评价方法研究进展[J]. 科技导报, 2024 , 42(3) : 75 -88 . DOI: 10.3981/j.issn.1000-7857.2024.03.007

Abstract

This study reviews the methods of measuring and assessing walking environments, which are classified into two categories:objective method and subjective method. The objective method is mainly based on GIS technology and data to measure neighborhood walkability at a meso or macro urban scale, which is relatively weak in measuring micro walking environment. The subjective method is mainly based on questionnaire scales and on-site participatory approaches to assess the walking environment at meso and micro scales, focusing on the pedestrian's subjective perception of the objective built environment, and considering the impact of individual walking ability, walking preference, and socio-economic attributes. With the rise and application of 3D GIS models, street view image data, and machine learning methods, objective methods have shifted from two-dimensional walkability measurement to three-dimensional measurement. Meanwhile, the research scale has also shifted from macro-scale to micro-scale, concentrating more on people and considering more refined walking environment elements that meet visual aesthetic needs from a human-oriented perspective. The subjective method turns to combine new technologies and methods such as machine learning, big data algorithm, virtual reality technology, and wearable physiological sensors to obtain the pedestrian's subjective perception of the walking environment. In the end, we propose future research trends and prospect the measurement and assessment of urban walking environments in China in the context of a humanoriented turn.

参考文献

[1] Duncan M. The influence of pedestrian plans on walk commuting in US municipalities[J]. Transportation Research Part A:Policy and Practice, 2023, 172:103664.
[2] Koohsari M J, Yasunaga A, Oka K, et al. Place attachment and walking behaviour:Mediation by perceived neighbourhood walkability[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2023, 235:104767.
[3] Kim B, Barrington W E, Dobra A, et al. Mediating role of walking between perceived and objective walkability and cognitive function in older adults[J]. Health & Place, 2023, 79:102943.
[4] 杨文越.城市交通出行碳排放及其影响机理[M].北京:商务印书馆, 2020.
[5] 刘珺,王德,朱玮,等.新旧城区休闲步行环境质量比较——以上海市鞍山新村和江湾新城为例[J].地理研究, 2015, 34(11):2195-2204.
[6] 周垠,龙瀛.街道步行指数的大规模评价——方法改进及其成都应用[J].上海城市规划, 2017(1):88-93.
[7] Ma X, Chau C K, Lai J H K. Critical factors influencing the comfort evaluation for recreational walking in urban street environments[J]. Cities, 2021, 116:103286.
[8] Zhou H, He S, Cai Y, et al. Social inequalities in neighborhood visual walkability:Using street view imagery and deep learning technologies to facilitate healthy city planning[J]. Sustainable Cities and Society, 2019, 50:101605.
[9] Jeon J, Woo A. Deep learning analysis of street panorama images to evaluate the streetscape walkability of neighborhoods for subsidized families in Seoul, Korea[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2023, 230:104631.
[10] Coffee N T, Howard N, Paquet C, et al. Is walkability associated with a lower cardiometabolic risk[J]. Health & Place, 2013, 21:163-169.
[11] Frank L D, Schmid T L, Sallis J F, et al. Linking objectively measured physical activity with objectively measured urban form[J]. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2005, 28(2):117-125.
[12] Ribeiro A I, Hoffimann E. Development of a neighbourhood walkability index for porto metropolitan area. How strongly is walkability associated with walking for transport[J]. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2018, 15(12):2767.
[13] Yang W, Zhou S, Zhen X. How does neighborhood walkability affect obesity?The mediating role of commute mode[J]. Journal of transport and land use, 2021, 14(1):737-759.
[14] 卢银桃.基于日常服务设施步行者使用特征的社区可步行性评价研究——以上海市江浦路街道为例[J].城市规划学刊, 2013(5):113-118.
[15] 杨文越,甄新瑜.多尺度步行环境对居民肥胖的影响机理——以广州为例[J].地理科学, 2022, 42(5):938-950.
[16] Li Y, Yabuki N, Fukuda T. Integrating GIS, deep learning, and environmental sensors for multicriteria evaluation of urban street walkability[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2023, 230:104603.
[17] Koo B W, Guhathakurta S, Botchwey N. Development and validation of automated microscale walkability audit method[J]. Health Place, 2022, 73:102733.
[18] Ma X, Ma C, Wu C, et al. Measuring human perceptions of streetscapes to better inform urban renewal:A perspective of scene semantic parsing[J]. Cities, 2021, 110:103086.
[19] Naik N, Philipoom J, Raskar R, et al. Streetscore-predicting the perceived safety of one million streetscapes, 2014[C]//IEEE, 2014:793-799.
[20] Kelly C E, Tight M R, Hodgson F C, et al. A comparison of three methods for assessing the walkability of the pedestrian environment[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2011, 19(6):1500-1508.
[21] Frehlich L, Friedenreich C, Nettel-Aguirre A, et al. Test-retest reliability of a modified International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) to capture neighbourhood physical activity[J]. Journal of Human Sport and Exercise, 2018, 13(1):174-187.
[22] Lusk A C, Da Silva Filho D F, Dobbert L. Pedestrian and cyclist preferences for tree locations by sidewalks and cycle tracks and associated benefits:Worldwide implications from a study in Boston, MA[J]. Cities, 2020, 106:102111.
[23] Perdomo M, Rezaei A, Patterson Z, et al. Pedestrian preferences with respect to roundabouts-A video-based stated preference survey[J]. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 2014,70:84-91.
[24] 陈志敏,黄鎔,黄莹,等.街道空间宜步行性的精细化测度与导控——基于虚拟现实与可穿戴生理传感器的循证分析[J].中国园林, 2022, 38(1):70-75.
[25] Nirjhar E H, Kim J, Winslow J F, et al. Sensor-based detection of individual walkability perception to promote healthy communities[J]. Smart Health, 2023, 29:100414.
[26] Handy S L, Boarnet M G, Ewing R, et al. How the built environment affects physical activity:Views from urban planning[J]. American Journal Of Preventive Medicine, 2002, 23(Suppl 2):64-73.
[27] Saelens B E, Sallis J F, Frank L D. Environmental correlates of walking and cycling:Findings from the transportation, urban design, and planning literatures[J]. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 2003, 25(2):80-91.
[28] Saelens B E, Handy S L. Built Environment correlates of walking[J]. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2008, 40(7):550-566.
[29] Cerin E, Saelens B E, Sallis J F, et al. Neighborhood environment walkability scale:Validity and development of a short form[J]. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2006, 38(9):1682-1691.
[30] Leslie E, Coffee N, Frank L, et al. Walkability of local communities:Using geographic information systems to objectively assess relevant environmental attributes[J]. Health & Place, 2007, 13(1):111-122.
[31] Sundquist K, Eriksson U, Kawakami N, et al. Neighborhood walkability, physical activity, and walking behavior:The Swedish Neighborhood and Physical Activity (SNAP) study[J]. Social Science & Medicine, 2011, 72(8):1266-1273.
[32] Cervero R, Kockelman K. Travel demand and the 3Ds:Density, diversity, and design[J]. Transportation Research Part D:Transport and Environment, 1997, 2(3):199-219.
[33] Cervero R, Sarmiento O L, Jacoby E, et al. Influences of built environments on walking and cycling:Lessons from Bogotá[J]. International Journal of Sustainable Transportation, 2009, 3(4):203-226.
[34] Pikora T, Giles-Corti B, Bull F, et al. Developing a framework for assessment of the environmental determinants of walking and cycling[J]. Social Science & Medicine, 2003, 56(8):1693-1703.
[35] Day K, Boarnet M, Alfonzo M, et al. The irvine-minnesota inventory to measure built environments[J]. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2006, 30(2):144-152.
[36] Millstein R A, Cain K L, Sallis J F, et al. Development, scoring, and reliability of the Microscale Audit of Pedestrian Streetscapes (MAPS)[J]. BMC Public Health, 2013, 13(1):403.
[37] Mateo-Babiano I. Pedestrian's needs matter:Examining Manila's walking environment[J]. Transport Policy, 2016, 45:107-115.
[38] Alfonzo M A. To walk or not to walk?The hierarchy of walking needs[J]. Environment and Behavior, 2005, 37(6):808-836.
[39] Ewing R, Handy S. Measuring the unmeasurable:Urban design qualities related to walkability[J]. Journal of Urban Design, 2009, 14(1):65-84.
[40] Yin L, Wang Z. Measuring visual enclosure for street walkability:Using machine learning algorithms and Google Street View imagery[J]. Applied Geography, 2016, 76:147-153.
[41] Moura F, Cambra P, Gonçalves A B. Measuring walkability for distinct pedestrian groups with a participatory assessment method:A case study in Lisbon[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2017, 157:282-296.
[42] Rollero C, De Piccoli N. Place attachment, identification and environment perception:An empirical study[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2010, 30(2):198-205.
[43] Bonaiuto M, Fornara F, Ariccio S, et al. Perceived residential environment quality indicators (PREQIs) relevance for UN-HABITAT city prosperity index (CPI)[J]. Habitat International, 2015, 45(1):53-63.
[44] Mendes De Leon C F, Cagney K A, Bienias J L, et al. Neighborhood social cohesion and disorder in relation to walking in community-dwelling older adults[J]. Journal of Aging and Health, 2009, 21(1):155-171.
[45] Mehta V. Walkable streets:Pedestrian behavior, perceptions and attitudes[J]. Journal of Urbanism, 2008, 1(3):217-245.
[46] Tabatabaie S, Litt J S, Muller B H F. Sidewalks, trees and shade matter:A visual landscape assessment approach to understanding people's preferences for walking[J]. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 2023, 84:127931.
[47] Leslie E, Butterworth I, Edwards M. Measuring the walkability of local communities using Geographic Information Systems data[C]//The 7th International Conference on Walking and Liveable Communities. Melbourne:the ACCESS Company, 2006.
[48] 陈曦,冯建喜.基于步行性与污染物暴露空间格局比较的建成环境健康效应——以南京为例[J].地理科学进展, 2019, 38(2):296-304.
[49] 王莹亮,肖健,李琪,等.城市建成环境对老年人步行出行的影响分析——基于重庆市江北区12个住区的实证[J].上海城市规划, 2022(3):122-128.
[50] Yang W, Zhen X, Gao W, et al. An examination of the impact of neighbourhood walking environments on the likelihood of residents of dense urban areas becoming overweight or obese[J]. Canadian Geographies/Géographies canadiennes, 2020, 64(4):619-633.
[51] Kuzmyak J R, Baber C, Savory D. Use of Walk Opportunities index to quantify local accessibility[J]. Transportation Research Record, 2006, 1977(1):145-153.
[52] 黄建中,胡刚钰,李敏.老年视角下社区服务设施布局适宜性研究——基于步行指数的方法[J].城市规划学刊, 2016(6):45-53.
[53] Hall C M, Ram Y. Walk score® and its potential contribution to the study of active transport and walkability:A critical and systematic review[J]. Transportation Research Part D:Transport and Environment, 2018, 61:310-324.
[54] Koohsari M J, Sugiyama T, Hanibuchi T, et al. Validity of Walk Score® as a measure of neighborhood walkability in Japan[J]. Preventive Medicine Reports, 2018, 9:114-117.
[55] Yin L. Street level urban design qualities for walkability:Combining 2D and 3D GIS measures[J]. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 2017, 64:288-296.
[56] Taleai M, Taheri Amiri E. Spatial multi-criteria and multi-scale evaluation of walkability potential at street segment level:A case study of tehran[J]. Sustainable Cities and Society, 2017, 31:37-50.
[57] Bedimo-Rung A L, Gustat J, Tompkins B J, et al. Development of a direct observation instrument to measure environmental characteristics of parks for physical activity[J]. Journal of Physical Activity & Health, 2006, 3(Suppl 1):176-189.
[58] Clifton K J, Livi Smith A D, Rodriguez D. The development and testing of an audit for the pedestrian environment[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2007, 80(1/2):95-110.
[59] Pikora T J, Bull F C L, Jamrozik K, et al. Developing a reliable audit instrument to measure the physical environment for physical activity[J]. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2002, 23(3):187-194.
[60] Saelens B E, Frank L D, Auffrey C, et al. Measuring physical environments of parks and playgrounds:EAPRS instrument development and inter-rater reliability[J]. International Journal of Management Education, 2006, 3(Suppl 1):190-207.
[61] Williams J E, Evans M, Kirtland K A, et al. Development and use of a tool for assessing sidewalk maintenance as an environmental support of physical activity[J]. Health Promotion Practice, 2005, 6(1):81-88.
[62] Alfonzo M, Guo Z, Lin L, et al. Walking, obesity and urban design in Chinese neighborhoods[J]. Preventive Medicine, 2014, 69:79-85.
[63] Hajna S, Dasgupta K, Halparin M, et al. Neighborhood walkability:Field validation of geographic information system measures[J]. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2013, 44(6):55-59.
[64] McGrath L J, Hinckson E A, Hopkins W G, et al. Associations between the neighborhood environment and moderate-to-Vigorous walking in New Zealand children:Findings from the URBAN study[J]. Sports Medicine, 2016, 46(7):1003-1017.
[65] Pikora T J, Giles-corti B, Knuiman M W, et al. Neighborhood environmental factors correlated with walking near home[J]. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2006, 38(4):708-714.
[66] Wimbardana R, Tarigan A K M, Sagala S. Does a pedestrian environment promote walkability?Auditing a pedestrian environment using the pedestrian environmental data scan instrument[J]. Journal of Regional and City Planning, 2018, 29(1):57-66.
[67] Sallis J F, Cain K L, Conway T L, et al. Is Your neighborhood designed to support physical activity?A brief streetscape audit tool[J]. Prev Chronic Dis, 2015, 12:E141.
[68] Van Dyck D, Sallis J F, Cardon G, et al. Associations of neighborhood characteristics with active park use:An observational study in two cities in the USA and Belgium[J]. Preventing Chronic Disease, 2013, 12:26.
[69] Sousa A, Santos B, Goncalves J. Pedestrian environment quality assessment in portuguese medium-sized cities[J]. Materials Science and Engineering, 2019, 471(6):62033.
[70] Troped P J, Cromley E K, Fragala M S, et al. Development and reliability and validity testing of an audit tool for trail/path characteristics:The path environment audit tool (PEAT)[J]. Journal of Physical Activity & Health, 2006, 3(Suppl 1):158-175.
[71] Zoellner J, Hill J L, Zynda K, et al. Environmental perceptions and objective walking trail audits inform a community-based participatory research walking intervention[J]. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 2012, 9:6.
[72] 杨俊宴,吴浩,郑屹.基于多源大数据的城市街道可步行性空间特征及优化策略研究——以南京市中心城区为例[J].国际城市规划, 2019, 34(5):33-42.
[73] Kim S, Woo A. Streetscape and business survival:Examining the impact of walkable environments on the survival of restaurant businesses in commercial areas based on street view images[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2022, 105:103480.
[74] 周梦茹,魏寒宾,边兰春.街道空间步行环境测评研究——以北京什刹海历史文化街区为例[J].上海城市规划, 2021(3):74-80.
[75] Rahman A. A GIS-based, microscale walkability assessment integrating the local topography[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2022, 103:103405.
[76] Alexander A, Bergman P, Hagströmer M, et al. IPAQ environmental module; reliability testing[J]. Journal of Public Health, 2006, 14(2):76-80.
[77] Rosenberg D, Ding D, Sallis J F, et al. Neighborhood environment walkability scale for youth (NEWS-Y):Reliability and Relationship with Physical Activity[J]. Preventive Medicine, 2009, 49(2/3):213-218.
[78] Saelens B E, Sallis J F, Black J B, et al. Neighborhoodbased differences in physical activity:An environment scale evaluation[J]. American Journal of Public Health (1971), 2003, 93(9):1552-1558.
[79] Sallis J F, Kerr J, Carlson J A, et al. Evaluating a brief self-report measure of neighborhood environments for physical activity research and surveillance:Physical activity neighborhood environment scale (PANES)[J].Journal of Physical Activity & Health, 2010, 7(4):533-540.
[80] Ferreira I A, Johansson M, Sternudd C, et al. Transport walking in urban neighbourhoods-Impact of perceived neighbourhood qualities and emotional relationship[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2016, 150:60-69.
[81] Koohsari M J, McCormack G R, Shibata A, et al. The relationship between walk score® and perceived walkability in ultrahigh density areas[J]. Preventive Medicine Reports, 2021, 23:101393.
[82] Bonaiuto M, Fornara F, Bonnes M. Indexes of perceived residential environment quality and neighbourhood attachment in urban environments:A confirmation study on the city of Rome[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2003, 65(1/2):41-52.
[83] Cerin E, Leslie E, Owen N, et al. An Australian version of the neighborhood environment walkability scale:Validity evidence[J]. Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science, 2008, doi:10.11819/cpr20170908a.
[84] Cerin E, Sit C H, Cheung M, et al. Reliable and valid NEWS for Chinese seniors:measuring perceived neighborhood attributes related to walking[J]. The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity, 2010, 7(1):84.
[85] 陈泳,毛婕,奚文沁,等.机动化时代大城市居民步行行为特征与需求分析——以上海中心城区为例[J].现代城市研究, 2016(7):103-112.
[86] 申洁,黄嘉欣,周婕,等.基于多维理论的城市住区建成环境步行性评价体系构建及应用——以武汉市为例[J].现代城市研究, 2021(10):51-57.
[87] Dean J, Biglieri S, Drescher M, et al. Thinking relationally about built environments and walkability:A study of adult walking behavior in Waterloo, Ontario[J]. Health & Place, 2020, 64:102352.
[88] Wang L, Han X, He J, et al. Measuring residents'perceptions of city streets to inform better street planning through deep learning and space syntax[J]. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2022, 190:215-230.
[89] Yao Y, Liang Z, Yuan Z, et al. A human-machine adversarial scoring framework for urban perception assessment using street-view images[J]. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2019, 33(12):2363-2384.
[90] Liao B, van den Berg P E W, van Wesemael P J V, et al. Individuals'perception of walkability:Results of a conjoint experiment using videos of virtual environments[J]. Cities, 2022, 125:103650.
[91] Tilt J H. Walking trips to parks:Exploring demographic, environmental factors, and preferences for adults with children in the household[J]. Preventive Medicine, 2010, 50:S69-S73.
[92] Kasraian D, Adhikari S, Kossowsky D, et al. Evaluating pedestrian perceptions of street design with a 3D stated preference survey[J]. Environment and planning B:Urban Analytics and City Science, 2021, 48(7):1787-1805.
[93] Zhu W, Guo S, Zhao J. Planning participants'preferential differences under immersive virtual reality and conventional representations:An experiment of street renewal[J]. Environment and Planning B:Urban Analytics and City Science, 2021, 48(7):1755-1769.
[94] Kim H. Feasibility of DRNN for identifying built environment barriers to walkability using wearable sensor data from pedestrians'gait[J]. Applied Sciences, 2022, 12(9):4384.
文章导航

/